Maybe in the end I was a bit disappointed, but while I was reading it I did enjoy Gwendy's Magic Feather. I was probably just waiting for some twist that never really came about. Unlike the first book nothing really bad actually happens to Gwendy and she never seems particularly tempted to push the buttons on the magic box. Basically she just gets super stressed out when the box reappears and helps solve a missing child case through some type of magical means that isn't fully explained. Maybe all will make a bit more sense in the next book. Since it was short and there's still a chance that this was all a set up for the final book in the series I'll go easy on the grade and say B.