And now for a book not on any of my lists... S by JJ Abrams and Doug Dorst. This book needs a bit of explanation... since it is a pretty original type of book. The name on the cover of the slipcase is S... but inside it is a book titled Ship of Theseus by V.M. Straka. Now this book is made to look like a very old copy from a library and is stuffed full of random things like postcards, articles, letters, pictures and even a napkin that continually try and fall out of the book. Also the margins are completely filled with notes between two people who are sharing the book back and forth... so really there are three different plots going on here.

First is the text of the book Ship of Theseus by the fictional author Straka. The book tells the strange story of a man with no memory that gets picked up on a weird ghost ship and travels around the world being manipulated to kill people while searching for a woman that he may or may not love or even know. Very strange, intriguing and unique...
Next are the footnotes (and introduction) to the text that seem to reveal another story about the relationship between Straka's translator and Straka himself and a mystery about who the true identity of the author really is. This part really reminded me of Pale Fire.
Third are the handwritten notes in the margins that reveal a story about two students that pass the book back and forth as they try and solve the mystery of who the author really was. They soon start thinking that someone is after them to not solve the mystery of who Straka really was and become more and more paranoid. They also leave random stuff for each other in specific parts of the book.
I have to give the book credit for being an original type of book and I don't really see how it could ever be reprinted in any different format without loosing something. And I was really into it while I was reading it... but in the end I have to give it only a B+. Mostly because the book brings up so many questions and doesn't answer quite a few of them... especially about what really happens off the pages between the two students. I shouldn't be surprised... after all J.J. Abrams did help create Lost.
Oh yeah...there's a Don Quixote reference too.
Oh yeah...there's a Don Quixote reference too.