Friday, November 30, 2012

Book # 44 Tess of the d'Urbervilles by Thomas Hardy


Progress- Book #14 of 100
I’ll start by saying that I was really looking forward to reading this novel. I remember watching the Masterpiece Theater adaptation sometime in high school and really liking the movie. When I saw it was on the list this was one of the first books I wanted to read. It turned out being the 14th book only because we couldn’t find it at any of the library book sales. We got lucky finding the book at a random used book store in Cambria, CA. This was a tiny little store with every bookshelf covered with books and tall piles of books in front of every shelf. We were pretty lucky we found it and escaped the store without being buried alive in a tidal wave of books.

I didn’t remember much of the story, just the ending and from that knew it was a tragedy. Saying it’s a tragedy is putting it lightly. The main character goes through so much, not by choice, but by circumstances she is thrown in. Despite everything she has high moral standards and keeps this throughout the book. Instead of getting angry or feeling sorry for herself, she takes on the problems of everyone else and never complains. There is one time when she finally stands up for herself and writes a letter to her husband- but that is it- the rest of the time she just deals with her life by working hard. That is one of the biggest problems I had with the book, I like happy endings and when people are rewarded for their hard work and attitudes. She does get one week of happiness right before she loses everything, but for me that wasn’t enough. She was too good of a person to have so many bad things happen too. As a reader you sympathize with her so much and want her to succeed and be happy. Thomas Hardy does this really well, with his writing style you get to care for Tess and wish the best for her.

The opening of the novel shows her at a may dance, happy and content in life where she gets a glimpse of her future husband. On the same day her father learns their ancestors were prominent Englishmen and he decides they are better than their peers. From that day on, her life quickly turns towards hardship and tragedy. Her father gets drunk to celebrate his newly discovered lineage and it’s up to Tess to take their goods to the market early the next morning to get their money needed for survival. They are poor farmers and cannot afford to lose the last trip to the market for the season. While traveling on the dark road with her younger brother, Tess falls asleep after a few hours and subsequently the family horse gets into an accident and dies. This is the first event in a series of events that lead to a very harsh and sad life for Tess. She feels terrible about the animal. Being the oldest of many siblings her mother urges her to visit their newly found relations to request help and or employment. Tess is a Durbefield and cares nothing of her D’Urberville relations, but has to go since the family really has no other options. What they don’t realize is the D’Urberville aren’t really her relations, they are people that bought the family name once they had enough money to buy the title. Arriving at the home she meets Alec D’Urbeville and she immediately knows he is bad. Alec is attracted to Tess and she goes to work for them and becomes a victim. The title of this section explains it all “Maiden No More.”

After Alec’s encounter Tess returns home and gives birth to a baby boy and begins to work in the fields. The baby dies and she decides to leave home and go to work on a dairy farm for a fresh start. Here she meets Angel Clare and they fall in love. He begs Tess to marry him, but she refuses because of her past. Angel father is a minister and Tess knows she wouldn’t be accepted. Angel pursues and pursues until they are finally married. On their wedding night Angel confesses to another love affair, and Tess decides to tell Angel everything expecting to be forgiven. Angel cannot believe it and punishes Tess by leaving her back with her family while he leaves to think things over and pursue a farm in South America. Back with her family Tess fakes her abandonment and leaves to go a work on another farm hoping Angel will send for her. She is too proud to ask for money from him family and too proud to let her own family know her situation. Instead of telling her mother she has nothing she sends them all of her money to repair the home.

As the time passes Alec and Tess meet up again and then Alec decides he must have Tess. He pursues her until and she refuses- still hoping Angel will come for her. Tess never gives up hope. In the end he does come for her and realizes how wrong he treated her, but it is too late.

Thomas Hardy teaches so many lessons about culture and society in this story and it’s Tess that suffers through all his lessons. She doesn’t want or care about a title, but her parents do. Their greed and false airs costs them a horse-which leads to sacrificing their daughter to Alec. Angel thinks he is forward with his thinking and decides not to become a clergyman like his father and brothers. He confesses to Tess of his own affair, but cannot forgive her for being raped. It’s a double standard, his first real test in life and he fails. Thomas Hardy also goes into religion and field work, but that’s too much for me to discuss right now. I’ll just say he was very critical of both!

I enjoyed this novel even though the story was depressing and sad it is a good book. It went deeper that I wanted, but I think most of the books on this list will be deep thought provoking books, that is how they become one of the top 100 greatest novels. I’ll give this a 94%

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Book # 27 - The Chronicles of Narnia (Part 2 of 7) - The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe by C. S. Lewis

TheLionWitchWardrobe(1stEd).jpg There are so many good books I haven't read that I rarely feel the need to re-read a book. When I started reading the books on this list I had previously read about two dozen of the books. Of those, maybe only three or four were books that I would imagine myself revisiting eventually. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe is one of those books. Having just finished it, I'm sure I'll be reading it still again someday (for the fifth time).

For those of you who don't know the story. Four siblings (Peter, Susan, Edmund and Lucy) go to live in a giant house in the English countryside during WWII and find a magic wardrobe. The wardrobe acts as a passageway to the magical land of Narnia. When the kids get there they learn that the White Witch has cast a spell over the land so that it is always winter. With the help of some talking beavers, the kids find Aslan the Lion who has come to restore order to Narnia. Then *spoiler* Aslan sacrifices himself to the White Witch to save the life of Edmund. Magically Aslan comes back to life, gets rid of the witch, restores Narnia, and places the kids as kings and queens of the land.

From start to finish, the book is completely enchanting. The style of writing is simple enough for children, but still charming enough to make adults smile. It is a relatively short book, so it is easy to read it just one sitting and won't test the attention span of children. There's also the whole Christ allegory thing too... so it is a good book to discuss with kids so that they can learn how metaphors work. Easily an A+.

Sunday, November 18, 2012

Book # 29 The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkein

The Hobbit
 It has probably been about fifteen years since I had first read The Hobbit. I remember really enjoying it, but didn't remember too many of the details except that there were a whole bunch of dwarfs, a few trolls, the encounter with Gollum, a giant dragon and a huge battle at the end. Actually that does sum of most of the book.

Reading it a second time was just as enjoyable. Bilbo, Gandalf and the dwarfs do have quite a few adventures for being a fairly short book. I can see how Peter Jackson could extend a five page battle sequence into a forty minute 3-D CGI epic battle for the ages and thus need to break the book into three movies.

The premise is pretty simple. Gandalf and a bunch of dwarfs recruit hobbit Bilbo Baggins to go with them on their quest to reclaim the treasure that was abandoned by their ancestors when the dragon Smaug attacked their mountain home. They have a bunch of adventures encountering trolls, goblins, elves, and giant eagles. At one point Bilbo becomes separated from everyone else while travelling through some tunnels under a mountain that is filled with goblins. While he is lost, Bilbo encounters the creature Gollum and plays a riddle game with him and is able to escape with Gollum's magic ring. Of course this is the ring that is so incredibly important in the sequel, The Lord of the Rings.


I'd easily recommend the book to just about anyone. It was in my top 50 before and is staying there. Once I had finished it,  I was tempted to re-read The Lord of the Rings next, but I think I'll force myself to wait on that for a bit. I'm giving The Hobbit an A+, but have to say that I thing the sequel is an even better read. It is basically another quest involving a hobbit, Gandalf and dwarfs, but the stakes are so much higher and the scope is larger. Also, the style of the two are somewhat different. The Hobbit has a friendly narrator that makes little jokes and doesn't make anything seem like the end of the world, while The Lord of the Rings is presented much more seriously and isn't geared toward children as much as The Hobbit is.

One last thing... it wasn't until I finished the book that I remembered that this existed....




Here are my updated rankings

1.Invisible Man
2. The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
3.The Hobbit
4. A Farewell to Arms
5.The Stand
6. The Name of the Rose
7.Frankenstein
8. Wind in the Willows
9.Anne of Green Gables
10. Rebecca
11.Anna Karenina
12. Sons and Lovers
13. Winnie-the-Pooh
14. Mrs. Dalloway
15.Atlas Shrugged

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Book # 20 Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy

Since a new film version is coming out soon, I figured now is a good a time as any to read Anna Karenina. I had actually started reading it about a month ago but stopped 2/3 of the way through to read a couple of other books. I didn't really know anything at all about this book or Leo Tolstoy beforehand... then I read the introduction of the book... and it totally reveals how the book ends! No spoiler alert or anything. So now I've learned that I should probably read a book's introduction afterwards (I also noticed the introduction to Frankenstein did the same thing).

Anna Karenina Despite being called Anna Karenina, the book actually has two stories that share equal space and Anna is really only in one of them. Her story is about how she falls in love with Count Vronsky and leaves her husband for him. She gets shunned from society and has to deal with it because her husband doesn't want to grant her a divorce. The alternating story is about this guy Konstantine Levin. He's also part of the upper class but prefers to live in the country. His whole story is that he proposes to a girl he loves, Kitty, she turns him down. He sulks for a few hundred pages. And then *spoiler* he proposes to her again, she accepts, they get married, have a baby, and Levin ponders a bunch of Russian political problems from the 1850's and tries to figure out the meaning of life. Around page 700 someone figures out that despite living in the same area and knowing the same people, Anna and Levin have never actually met. So they finally meet and have a nice chat.

The Anna storyline kept me interested most of the time. She's an interesting character and I'm sure people will have different opinions of her. I could see how that would make an interesting film. The Levin storyline is a bit on the boring side. There are endless discussions about Russian political and economic problems that I have no clue about. It gets a bit boring after awhile. It seems that much of the Levin story is actually based on Tolstoy's real life. So he pretty much throws in all of his political viewpoints into this story. I could care less about "the Serbian problem" or what kind of agreements landowners should make with peasants to tend to their land.

There are quite a few really good sequences, most notably the scene where Anna has a mental breakdown. That part of the book uses stream of consciousness to show her thoughts. I guess at the time this was considered pretty groundbreaking. I also liked the chapter where Levin's and Kitty's son is born. Overall it was enjoyable, but there were just a few too many political discussions that are completely irrelevant to me. Now I'll have to see the movie to compare it...

One last thing... the way Tolstoy describes Anna did not make me imagine Keira Knightley at all. Maybe I just have a bias against her, or maybe I just can't forget all of the horrible faces she made in A Dangerous Method.  A-